How to Pick the Right Instagram Content Agency

And not regret it 3 months later.

If your brand feels invisible on Instagram, here’s the real fix (spoiler: it’s not just more posts).

You’re not alone.

You’ve tried the DIY route.
You’ve hired freelancers.
You’ve even posted We’re back a few times hoping the algorithm shows mercy.

But let’s face it without consistent, engaging content, Instagram becomes a ghost town for your brand.

And that’s why you’re here — looking for a real Instagram content creation agency to take things off your plate and move the needle.

Here’s how to find the right one without wasting time (or money).

‍

Start With This: Know What You Actually Need

Before you even Google anything, ask yourself:

• Do I want strategy and content?
  
  
• Or just someone to post what I already have?
  
  
• Is my goal engagement? Leads? Sales?
  
  
• Do I want them to handle captions, stories, reels — or just visuals?
  
  

Know your goals before shopping around.

‍

Red Flags to Avoid

Not all agencies are worth your budget. Some just want to schedule and forget.

Here’s how to spot the no-go zones:

• No clear process — if they can’t explain their system in under 5 minutes, run.
  
  
• No niche or past results — generalists can’t build brand-specific content.
  
  
• Stock-looking visuals — Instagram is about originality. You can’t stand out with Canva templates everyone’s seen.
  
  

 Look at past work, not just their proposal deck.

‍

What the Right Agency Should Do

Here’s what a great Instagram content creation agency brings to the table:

• Strategy-first: They build around your goals, not trends.
  
  
• Content that’s on-brand and native to IG.
  
  
• Storytelling that sells — not just gets likes.
  
  
• Insights and real performance tracking.
  
  
• Collaboration: They feel like an extension of your team.
  
  

 Sometimes smaller = better attention.

How to Test the Waters Before Committing

‍

Don’t jump into a 6-month contract on Day 1.

Here’s how to keep it safe and smart:

• Start with a trial month or project
  Ask for a content pack or 15-day plan.
  
  
• Request a sample post
  Give them a piece of your old content and see how they’d reimagine it.
  
  
• Look for strategic input
  Ask: What would you do in the first 30 days if we hired you?
  
  

Strategy matters more than quantity.

‍

Your 6-Step Checklist Before You Sign

Want to make sure you’re choosing right?

Use this:

1. They’ve worked with your industry or a similar one
   
   
2. They ask about your audience before pitching content
   
   
3. They understand IG formats: Reels, Carousels, Lives, Highlights
   
   
4. They talk metrics like saves, shares, reach, conversion
   
   
5. They sound excited about your brand
   
   
6. Their work feels better than what you’re doing now
   
   

If they tick 5/6, they’re worth a deeper convo.

‍

The Best Ones Don’t Just Create — They Care

Let’s be honest.

There’s no shortage of agencies.

But the ones that actually grow your brand on Instagram aren’t just executing tasks. They’re:

• Watching your industry.
  
  
• Testing hooks and formats.
  
  
• Repurposing your long-form content.
  
  
• Helping you look good in front of your boss or client.
  
  

Look for this level of care. It’s rare.

‍

Bottom Line: What Actually Matters

A great Instagram content creation agency won’t just fill your feed.
They’ll help fill your funnel.

And the right one will feel like they’ve already been part of your brand for years even if it’s just been 30 days.

‍

Ready to Work With an Agency That Actually Gets It?

At Bricks, we don’t just create content.
We build content that performs.

Scroll-stopping posts
Strategy that drives results
And a team that treats your brand like their own

 Let’s talk →

‍